The Seeds of Pakistan . . . !

Mother India: “By the pricking of my thumbs,

Something wicked this way comes.�

Hi, Everyone! In 1937, the Congress came right out and revealed its goal of total control in the governing of India. They had the Hindus in their pocket, and were under the impression that the Muslims would also happily crawl in there. Well, they certainly had a rude awakening!

In his book, History of the Freedom Movement in India, vol. III (hence forth in all the posts to be called HFMI, vol. III) page 551-552, R. C. Majumdar, a noted historian, writes:

“The result of the elections held in 1937 belied the claims of both the Congress and the Muslim League. . . . It was a clear indication that the Congress organization had no contact with the Muslim masses and had very little influence over them. The Congress could not therefore advance any reasonable claim to represent the Muslims. . . .

It is not a little curious that the Muslim League had a specially bad record of election success in those Provinces like Bengal, the Punjab, Sindh and North-West Frontier Province where the Muslims formed the majority community, and fared much better in the Provinces which had a strong Hindu majority with a significant and vocal minority.�

[Point to note:

·        the Muslims of  the very provinces which went to Pakistan in 1947 had happily voted for nationalist Muslim parties in 1937. . . !

A Central Federation at this time would have bound them to a united India.]

“The reason is that the Muslim League had no special positive programme which distinguished it from the other parties and had no local influence in any Province. It throve only on its assumed character as a bulwark of defence against Hindu attack. The Provinces with a Muslim majority had no genuine fear of such an attack, and were not therefore susceptible to the propaganda of the League.

It is only when the Muslim masses learnt to look upon the problem from an all-India perspective that the Muslim League emerged as the most powerful Muslim organization. . . .

The credit of Jinnah lies in the fact that he succeeded in developing this political consciousness among the Muslims within an incredibly short time. . . .�

And to do that, he too brought religion into politics.

“He touched the chord of religious feelings of the Muslims which have always proved a potent factor in Muslim politics. ‘The Mullahs of the countryside were soon up in arms against the Congress propagandist . . .’ The Congress mass contact movement, which had made some headway, collapsed under the attack of the Mullahs.�[1]

To continue (HFMI, vol. III, page 551-552):

“The intransigence of the Congress high command helped its growth. They took their stand on the theory that the Congress represented the whole of India . . . They ignored the Muslim League as having no influence over the masses and only representing a ‘microscopic minority’ of the Muslims . . . But they discounted the idea that there may be a national urge among the Muslims limited to their own community . . . and though a nationalist may disapprove such a development, a Statesman can ignore it at his peril.

Jawaharlal Nehru in particular, among the Congress leaders must be held highly guilty in this respect. . . .

It [Congress] did not learn the obvious lesson of coming to terms with the Muslim League till by its [Congress’s] folly the League had attained a position when it could dictate its own terms, and demanded Pakistan as the only basis of settlement.�

This is how R. C. Majumdar wraps it up in a nutshell:

·        “In 1937 his [Nehru’s] outright rejection of Jinnah’s offer of Congress-League Coalition Ministry ruined the last chance of a Hindu-Muslim agreement.�

So much for the much-touted Congress Hindu-Muslim unity demand of the Congress. . . !

·        As I said, making a demand is one thing but without follow-up by action it is just so much hot air.

But what exactly was it that Congress and Nehru did?

Find out tomorrow!

Anurupa


[1] HIFM, vol III, R. C. Majumdar, page 568.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CAPTCHA Image

*

HTTP/1.1 200 OK Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2026 07:14:24 GMT Server: Apache X-dlm-no-waypoints: true X-Pingback: http://anurupacinar.com/xmlrpc.php Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="nurturing-of-the-pakistan-plant.pdf" Content-Transfer-Encoding: binary Accept-Ranges: bytes Cache-control: private Pragma: private Expires: Mon, 26 Jul 1997 05:00:00 GMT Content-Length: 33948 Keep-Alive: timeout=5 Connection: Keep-Alive Content-Type: pdf %PDF-1.7 %âãÏÓ 19 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 20 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /PZ 1 >> endobj 20 0 obj <> stream xœåZYoÛF~ׯ˜¼µ€³æòVßÜ6umÔEÜ hÃ+r-mL.iRÔ'@ÿng©Ã¢›b¨Pr)P¢HÎßÎ|s�± 7ƒ—¸€›[üñq?Ç}Ðù±§¿P :ÑŠ zwð®×Ñê >,.hu[ÔV[¤óÚÚÁú%Ƕˆa™–í€vNÿî™ðsÔ¹ÆOí9­w»8øã|*¤uÚÚÖÖ‘?×K1§‡çîI€]b7ÉÓ¹1ö¨Îš:±h×v-pL‡˜]WAÚóáæ»ßó$Ë!ÝA6äðžÝ‹4cÞLfßßBïR5r]Ð ÈÕZ£†„v·˜o²FÔ&”>­,­B5U¬¥ô;.l»iéZڢϗ¹?à £ ú“B��èÃ8JüÒ8ºçÆ"ƒ»(¹ç>d‘äü>‚3!æe"’)³5Õß„P«à^Âà. ‚h¬æ’/ÕuæÛiÔäÿN¶IkRÅóW•§ÆÎÑ)ƒá:D×lÛXº½qÍÅl-½L¬ow@«��Û8pkÓÀa¾5´Ü{q‡§ƒx3E(Sç™Ì“5SÁͲmSÞ�Ìèˆ)�6SÊ{k`–a®&eÇHyt¥–ײì1-Ìwžk•ºiªÁ€ç1¦nh¾Âƒ1›(ÛžYuÊ&*´AÁ±`žÇãlQÓûW¥¼ØêVêëv‰eWÕí¶A[-é͈SÔ)Ñ�yÂ!Œ�ä<ždLÈë)ˆfĤøì§´×uˆÛujQÅfÑ–¹ï0æsÌÌ×LY�:&Ñ�Wñƒ®Ôõ.äŒö>f�rUzñ¸¢3$¶´É¬¬³—w“]kC‹ó›^BtY^¯!¯†<—ë,Eˆ.1LÛ´ÁBcq,[)ÎÓéþüÚ¾¿F]·ÅYF×Z}ÑhËFáì%�xöÍì�Û²Öÿ…ÕÞ endstream endobj 21 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 22 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /Annots [ 6 0 R 8 0 R ] /PZ 1 >> endobj 22 0 obj <> stream xœí[ÛrÛ6}÷WlßÚïd^2ušÖI“NÓhšÎxò“‰˜h�²ªÏhœ™ünw)ùBYRYŠD·òX¶. ìîYÀ=æ=|Ázð¿?ÀÉ{ü‘@�õš×œ_þø¯HŽúðøg ,ûêóþž÷z‹o K ϯz³ ÖâÎÜm |�9žëùÄÅÁã¿ú.ü¤Þà×’®­;Zê¶c?À l†u,ïÆ;°ÈðÍ ¶K»µx–-o]©Wß|Dí;ÛžÍìÐY±W÷™óóeטð‘øsóÙŸHŸº8v+òC'd¾’3ö8ùþ‡÷ÐIW½ùª™ˆf[цÜc·€ØN �Ë£a / æ ”¸NpÉ<—*…’›z µ†:p!/d%âZjÅ ùút Î-DÃöZ¿ÑÜX«Ì�ãD =kÞäœXﯞ¹¬7¹Ìr˜ãØt»G=æO&`°²fwv,&8ß æMÈÊéã«’‹Ç<ÏZ+ËÏ7Ý1míÇx:LZ~°Ò ™å>Îòývë U�¡ÆR“¬ ª*H_BÁùP×"™p|ýLÓì�ßH…¼&FÃD‰¦ɝޱy  dâØm8ý}³+ä¶=ˆè=ι,ˆË‰á\Õ”å?-¡ù>¡ô±ÂXk¶•è, ½µÆ|Ó'ÀýO—`oMÚm�9`nø  ¶Ãù­�a”5&°§X¾KÊ~ Ep".0÷Q Ÿé\@©«´�ð&À3™f9~×TÝ\�Aà®’Lb”W˜Oæ?Û¶˜íßÁsO Ú”èái.Õ‘Yí°|¦UjDUÁˆW Ss©ò1Œd•Q‚„•ŠŒL(M½”JñŒÁïüLV5–0eŽod)U%©‡Úž ²¬J}&ÔâZ޹QG2™µ}HTÃâÈ9B'8¦5Ä`ÌàY&â3*Ò0õc};Iê�!<cÅÇŸA—‚Ð-1"ÀX ã}¨°›Uqœ.¬ÒÝÈg½Ð™Ñ17òW÷§ÖÖ¬‹=´½®x\ØÒÏè?ènÏUJnƒEÃvμh=¾Y`»cÝ—u˜AÝÍè÷¸ªzRˆ;+ß¿ËdNëùj$ _+P¯XÀˆ2—“„?MŽD¨¯qMࢫ¹½'ðÏ éaž- pµ°�;-;³ê¦Ô®áêµÝ§4b ¼ÆJA`†&·##k¬ù{º³AÂG#‹HÒA 4WR“*eBkƒ(¡�쑬éÌ�¨èÓ\ž4¢�þiˆ�DZ(›ýí+5‚M·Ž°pH2}„}YUªÝ5Z~Û{n8¯O‘�m:±n–2NeŠ5’š‡ÎH5G °ê�’׃?e,ŒÃ+©r7Õ£m¥ë%ûg¡Û°¼¶kÑA±fŸ±Ù`l`HD�ž�‹BQ•"–<ÏÇtf¢šˆZ\"ü%•dsí’Õä€bMˆŒX|vÌÅN¯#–5#¹¿P‰äAôzèÇ2Íð¯‚pCGA�u5Þ†WµŒ¡6‚ǸÚÖà }!¶³eäúÌsÖ“�æ›î˜Y÷c<æÕhS+èðîA§.òêŒF}IAüN›³I+ Y×¢Ù¿ i]Áoͪšç7Ñ^ÝÅ4(Šs¢Œ›y:>“ò–�xÍÿ?ÃÙðæÜñê¢/AyÛÞ^Þº|ewpk±2Çõ]/€<Œ‘ÀóÉcn>Îáí}Ÿ}@tæGöÈs"oêð…— �Á¿5«[ù·½@xÐ endstream endobj 23 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 24 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /Annots [ 9 0 R ] /PZ 1 >> endobj 24 0 obj <> stream xœí]ÝrÛ6¾÷Sœ½kgl†ÿ¤ö.MÚÝt¶Ý´ñÎv&ÍDB$�PAR=F²�éëî(Ù¢,*’#E¢RÛ$Aâ|:ç;?ÀÛVÙø‚9Øð#~½‡·ïð[ ¶eë×–~ý^‘]}w Ï~pÀqWÇo'ðýí•ÝKØ9ð�»öæ §2OEa`y�„$ÅÕ³ßn}x)®~Á÷Ž©=VZ59<�ó€ÐŠ}Çs‚û¡øøÃAúìLþØu�̉�‘÷ÇæøDuÔw­À…qQàY¡+ˆnSxû�¤•àMÍD ¤†—”ç X ϧ’qpF¾{ ëOÕ9…¢Ìp@‰hx ¥P‡YùA�¨©,* º½ÆžÙ9øÛÌg�œdw�ë%%:¼ÒFvG.kÜ4A–�%²NÐâ®á¥´à5©1ÈÀøî «‰$Y,ä$U I Vÿл3 8‘åEÎ6H>¾B&ÞŤ±=�`3ˆ»¬@g,¥åš7™’ª"Å8�GJ+}0e3¦9™VÇœ­_*„¤j$/)¼©Q4ÑflÖìGÌ‹¬‘ ³¨« ™¸QChh0ö®Zj„„fRý¶Bé ¦=ƒˆ.fkH¬Ûdüsmæ' ÒÓ�ýJ*äì‡/j¹ïmÃ÷­÷îá�Ëìö2dz<ÏU·Ã\"\> c¿Ëû@N2�s˜CäXnlû¸N’.;^h¹Þãb¢ž±gø †'ï€êÀ��”Pûñ±ª-çÄéê*ÉY�WU¢Wйm»Èö¿B~Pñî Q`”ZS –~ÿ ž—i­J–ýñ ÂâÚÉ ýQW‰Tö¯ ÆlË ~L'*°{MdÍêUòÌÊ”N)þ‡a¡u:toߊÄ^c¿:^¦D&&éïß¶QÈ Ä ª\oc#ɇRÌ9M3º¶É *Ûrâ�¬%º~WµþEIÖÐO¦—„0Ñ0¦Dêí×+<)(Œ)LQ1.£ª¼óœ¶:Y3<›¨KÔ-&’˜¥õæYN0À6ª·JØù§fõ*ß^.¯¶ÈË^=tbdâh«`ŠAÖÊ�ÔÜ« ä#OEÉ&,ií ZmSR²ë½MBZavXˆ? Ù¨N«=�ÐnO"21£²,Ôò»Rt—‹f\O$�‘²V ñ8¦ f¥*V¥1µTC«¨oz Úºèç_Ì£�T§��êôý–ƒv/B!Ð15åœUÈ‚³dñI¨ÛB}­sñò[J½×‹H½XŸäBT­Ê©Ò•ýÛ¼<Ç ‡RÌwbosCoÙã4ù�뎬Ñ#kÚ=cÏ·OÞgŽw”Z—÷Tj]ÎF5úö.*„6„jW,U4N8_ÀûfÌ8zЇ¡{JÑ{ /Þ-væd¦|ØÒû�阫¦‹^–‹lÌ£âG»«Aœ ˜HQ´MªˆjJ“†·Û—ù §3ªÁšJ’Ô,Aä”×ÀŸª²d[�·¯yî3ô«sä%ʳÉ�6*Ń•¼È´ h_¦É´ =Ñàô ™$Ó‚dZ�L Ò%s’iA2-H¦if¦é’:^.‚cM Ò�ÉM ’iA2-H¦É´ 3Ó‚t2:¼L‰Lx¦É´ 4Ó‚dZ�.J#M ’iAzÞ}Äx5åÕ¸«õÒ‘åù¡DP@€n Bîýao¾ôÙ_b³ˆn¬gäàŒo,m>óòà„kÆx’?ìõù!ôb endstream endobj 25 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 26 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /Annots [ 10 0 R 11 0 R 12 0 R ] /PZ 1 >> endobj 26 0 obj <> stream xœÝ[ÛrÛ6}×Wìc2c#¼�—¾9IÓ$ÓdÚZ™v&ñ(B"’Px±Fý‹8ùà.(S&©‹UY2ÅHã‘D\÷`±gwk„:¾`¼Å¿Ïðñ ?ЈV¾Ö|ùë7¬1<³W:èFõ|8†_‡ms—°µá×e�Ö.Ð7OfµÈ±)1©EmFñàÙ?C ^ÊÁŸøÞ2µ#H{o—_·ÕI'€Câ0éݳލžZ¡ºg»j[w•¬Ã>>�§W0|«ª)i·LàžÒ•ÖtÒCQtþ& ƒ2™¤<ËðK‹<çü bÎs‘L@$ª" ™Ï� \LS�AÊ?óQÎE†?2¹Àþ¼¥RAœjê›îš¦Nïæ‰J6hT±‰n{í*'ЍÑÔ–€¼æé,äQ¬p‹Ùg™Š|, €rª�b0’E’óô¼†×·‚Y(“ª¨²…gêWÊÇ2Ec8bI"q�b ¯44+FáF´ ÝÁ)ôdkÚ¶ÙÆ«4CäæGMÀ�sß2ÃÎJ h} =—PÃ\ôGëj p³–¶¨¥›Ä4 ÕÙ¹FìÛ¡ÐÜ�Þrì9�ô^×uâRºn=ä¶M%žåìh vj{”¥èŸD­ž©AŒUóDM®îî§yM™)ѽCiG·xhæJ|²ŒJb£o˜Á ùcL2f×è -‘Âk1 Ëèiü&C·0Šd‘WŽÎ;©¸<Â2²Ù•6,b=alꮄsè�('.€Lž¡{Ì¿âZŽXÍ\m7û`© ÝFÒ3× \®úÃ�“.„2=4€k…ªÑä(T¤¨At?ý¡mÇTt*õ˜Š¨µ§ÔBÓ!º³’»é#Q£¹-Ÿ#‘Ô#ÃÙ¨èqALÌ/7¯ «Gh‰eºŒº— ?=Q-B¶9Êöp=‰²©ÞÔ›@d)Ÿ°4àÁY™ Ë‹4Qß•ÌÙ(ä±J€M˜H²-]ÄrqÍ‘�b‘ “‹,+xöééÉ3_18ÛÏ7âåÝî ^–·†Âà%�BQÏž¢Î°Ñˆ*'öû"�Õ$ô©J÷„bBÀ§òýƒ2a¹:+z™¸dó¹àŠ~G.+Ë÷z®rÛ꤉e_ÐĽcFm .þeŠi¹ ãà-’HïYÊæ,¹É6š: §ÒåiŽÔø½À©Œ34ˆe Æ¡AóÇÆãÅœr2Ö‰zþ·L¿(~Xím�)±V³ § ˜Ù:i( Â¥Ô ý†œ—9‚‹bR ÓaŸ�îY†:¹œ"a¿üŸ3ßÄ5 ‡˜æZy¿½—0eé2ñ²úè7•î– \ížl³u 3—Ê:ÆÅ YVß>çÉݶÀ-²Ü.þüöÐÆÏø×B�y­l•ÍPá:x´/XµrÚä y�ï›ÓÖu×Q·Ö ðã8Yyôƒ w×tßNm;öáNE¢ûpæa²ò&ÅG=º…KÛÿ U§Õ¹_{â߇‹K‹9 ;d+(OµtNÏÐ뜱�¥Ùïy˜À" ?o= (¯ðoq¨\‚ĶÜ>¬­cn8š—>�Ón»t×ãNãQt´Õ«³ñ:¸—¢kVuåÄp ôpuO^^LYª@«~¦…ý[®a£òœk?Õ·æµ”âyRˆÙøÈ6©±‚½ªAÖ¨u ™E,ë‘!{ìMt;ð˜×›:¹‹¤¡Zxšî®XäE=)ÝÉ“?Ê2vË�ô0™\ª­»z¼v÷x=ß-×`PCÑ D³=…b<0PÏ]Ïq³þ<\Öw…Ìžãvª£º‡ÆÝêaèÕžøÞ›ë�ƨۥtÍý9žQøy±¦'�õc‘ÆIË»¯±¿§Â`›þíù/–HltM�U¥û»ÞÞØ£½šrծξ.1-Û¢H¾@qÿ:ÔVß=Žàò¡c?dC"ºn9#•4¡¦G+»çeÁ3°k»ö(ÿ™úV¦ÏB endstream endobj 27 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 28 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /Annots [ 13 0 R 14 0 R 15 0 R ] /PZ 1 >> endobj 28 0 obj <> stream xœí[mo›Hþί˜�wRºÙ–…�½¦­ÔªRÛXw'Eù°gc›Æ@ 8UÉý”û{7¤çÈÚW0¨�9Ú7fž™ÙyvÀ”HEñ‚/@á þ}‚›[üš%ôñ2üóñ5ŽXX¿MàòÆ7í“9¼œXt÷’°wâçï´ÚÁv ó´K9’iKGÁ4´.ÿœØp[ð³G´¦ÚæÂa?Ê\Râ0)˜ÜNFv´çŽ [Z™îŠ^¹¹–Ÿ÷�I€·ÄÛ$Û¶/xÇ¼ÕæD2Ïq%(á" nÿd7¿üz “7ù¨5u6¢¹‰V°®cÅCæŽ�yžcŸ°ç�ÉNT4³Ó±Ðd„=Ųû÷l©Êvø§†!ú\WJ“àðíjÉ�ëíÇ#œ*0×1dK^ÄÑ"ñÓþˆ“» Z`CYæû€Íñj�qz:õgyï°Ý@(E„Ù�‡.¹‹[’Ùƒßë» Ít„ö‘?ƒt}Ÿø¡ÿ·N :Uv)êW©qìùR–s³žÏƒ$DEÿúZvÑY0Ít') K>_/ÖiÎ0×ê$Q0ª0|¼f‰Â<·“T1>�FLQ$kHQÊ:;¸ hË=zÄöÊñûÑ׳ endstream endobj 29 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 1 0 R /LastModified (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Resources 2 0 R /MediaBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /CropBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /BleedBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /TrimBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /ArtBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 841.890000] /Contents 30 0 R /Rotate 0 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB >> /Annots [ 16 0 R 17 0 R 18 0 R ] /PZ 1 >> endobj 30 0 obj <> stream xœíXÛNÛ@}÷WÌ#Héf/žõú•R�¨�ÒÖª*…<¸Ø­š\$«ßY7Á u_”�¢X»3³sfŽÏÚá =NràpAߟ0žÐOœñbT\|>'‹©sÀðL€�Ëù ��Ã7‡„ZÇ»‡þxAlNæÿ%O#Sè¢öàzæ ¿.œ¦Î'úÔ¤Ö­MŽÖ)�(™4J ,�)�öeÚšË]�M6Ú’¶Éʹœv´³®d(|m:ž@pa­l•jöw¨Œ+˜… ÑkŒ¹.r'§}­>SWEË®*³ÖÕ±;yhìºÿg%SJÚ`ï8Ó‹­bHˆo£=CªÖ!÷pW#2ƒ¢ªÿAÎ'qi£4�³•Û¼cÉö€O `R`À|e0bpÏÓùnÃiLœöYc9k#vþEE[ù—»‘:EPãAþ_†ük½«c¬’ku�ÿ·(ÿ�ûÞ„÷³ÎÃytóãuj¿ë1ãW¢ÀÇ8΢O™=�èÛÃÇøMŸpù>;—ˆ6#zUomDÿÎÇöÞË×¢ ¨*Ifò–²¸(à�¨qßÿ@ð~tzWGyž³ûëÛ(ai6½:^Æîÿ£à¤Á—FÛø±ê/;øÛ”—~NÉi˜rµ‹Ìè˜�ÌCm‰^Nÿ‚/}÷îÃkª®)2"^+T>.x [††!èò÷`Ã_ÍËi endstream endobj 1 0 obj << /Type /Pages /Kids [ 19 0 R 21 0 R 23 0 R 25 0 R 27 0 R 29 0 R ] /Count 6 >> endobj 3 0 obj <> endobj 5 0 obj <> endobj 7 0 obj <> endobj 31 0 obj <> /Length 9795 >> stream xœ�}iT”Gö÷mâ™sÝýa&²;  Hˆ Ø81®ˆ$ ¢0ˆKÄ 61êH0LPPÅA6%c2ˆ‚q—hŒÊ""qAPψˆæËÐ�9'9']ï‡;TnW=O'ï¿>ô©§êÖ­[÷þî­åYZ3{ölÐh4666˜Á_Lj%r8¡V.”ËisüeŒYá#_Ò&¼D.§j%Œ1¹!Òr^"TÑLf³ù˜Íf¹#ʇ— +¡ J@¹ýžZ¼hä*™•bÆØ+cÇŽ4¨¨\L‚FA½�—õ.«€–'%%ýøã�/^¼€W_}5,,ìÇ¢c’¢åBFXRÐÓl6Ër Ú牗+r¶2jE+*vñ›2»»»÷ööbmDDÄ¢E‹:;;þùgë½X·Î(6âX¼‚»2³ô9=Œ1EHQÿãÞ�Î'‘ö¨Ø)þŽ=:33“vqäÈóØH¨àMx�@üžËfcc£Øí‚R>Ô`˜Ç¾¨Šˆ("ƒ*Á °ä¼l`¡9Æd2­_¿>))‰÷><4Ø€¿¿ÿÌ™3.\ˆdW¯^=xðà‹/c]]]ááá666 ,HJJ~þüypppxx¸ƒƒœ?þСC/_¾¤ËÍÍ >|È­.ÏJaaasæÌ±··€îîî‹/¶¶¶†……-[¶ìðáÃ'OždÒÞ™øúúúúú¾óÎ;ÈêñãLJîîîæÌ±ÕèÑ£1â"Ymm-'cRÂËÛ·o¿xñÂÞÞ>**jÛ¶mÙœ§»»{ss3^úùùýý²²óçÏSƒ­[·Nè%66kW­ZµdÉ’ÞÞÞôôt3xó½{÷zzzöôô`¹££cTTŽ·¼¼üË/¿õ0RÔ±˜°¸vt:]zzú�7h÷÷ïß§¢h4OOO8uê™r`ŒmÚ´iæÌ™W®\IHHxþüùªU«"##µZí–-[è müðáÜœœ×_�ó™?¾ŸŸß† ~üñG^ȉéB›×Ž=úÃ?DxaB4Ìž={Ò¤IÐÒÒ"˜™¼úê«qqqãÆ�;|øðÊ•+`Íš5sæÌùàƒÐT˜Ìf3BðÑ£G·oß LIIINNÎÌÌ|ùò%†Y®ú5ÍñãÇ&Mš4vìØG�q3Ì›7/11L&Ó÷ß]]]>twwýõ×Ïž=+[”+Ùh4òîüýý ³³Sq®´×ÀÀ€Ùlöòò*((à«ØÄÄÄû÷ï··· h“™ð_ h&--íúõëX¢Õj7F£‘ÆyOOϨ¨¨žžžŠŠ 9ÔçççÏœ9óÌ™3ùùùÏž=3›Í7oÞ;;;:6\ ¿þúëvvv;wˆˆˆˆ8wî888,_¾œO¯¾úª»»;<þœÂ'ˆ×^{mÓ¦Mnnn­­­iii111‰‰‰_}õÕË—/7�=zþü¹<½öÚkŸ|òɸqã¶oßÞÒÒ‚å'Ož€“'OÒÉhÑ¢Eˆ›íÛ·ÿý÷Œ±––°³³óõõ¥Jxíµ×p§Ó(n `Ò¤IŒ$[[[,ïëëã}uuu!gNTZZZZZ –S!7®‚ŒñÜœÌð’ááá��F¦üŃÜ=Qó<ÎÑÑÑ^^^k×®å+Tl¢Óé8Îx«ìììëׯ߻wOfø¿e2ZÝL¬0!nàÞ½{yyy˜¿qã.œmllxžë­·�ìÒ¥KÈ|Ö¬Y~ø¡V«­ªªBè`wo¼ñøÁƒ@Žé4 ŽF‚3Œ,tP›Ô3lllÐq�;6<6ä–––Ö×ׇµ¸Ð¡'@aaa|Ý-wÍÉüüübbb°ÄÍÍÍÞÞÞÏÏÏÏÏïáÇEEE¸‚AJ77·ŒŒŒææf<丙ÍfœìííM&“ƒƒCppðµk×f̘!`ÂÁÁ¡··= ù£›!˜À2®lÚ´ 3xL¬hi4¥§§§Édâ›)¬•½&L˜ð·¿ý­¤¤¤¿¿ŸöÈcCû@Ç›8q"ðxÕÞÞÞÞÞk×®¥úÅ„HBùžëÔ©Sï½÷^^^î ‘shhhjjê™3gpíŒ' tÀf³�¬««‹ ƒÐAïäI«Õò;êx2ÄFÖ±±±öööÇŽãl9sÆØ»ï¾»|ùrÚ#]<ñ̸qãÒÓÓq‡Ì{¿uëÖ† 6lØpõêU.ɸqãrrrž?^ZZ*(“sãó ½½=c,))©««‹{§wppðððhjj¢vtt€žžºÂcŒåçç{zzbÔáëN>Lä€þ ³gÏÞ¿?³\ðá6 ',¤wvv...¾páBMM�0®I,’уt8aÑUó¿þõ/„dLLŒÀ‹£¾I(ç¹fÍšÔÔÔÓ§OïÞ½‡Ä}…îpù|óæM”8'æf^»v-‡)F/d^VVÆ] wvH�‘‘±|ùr ¸¹¹ÉcgŒ¹¹¹åää`0CÊúúú†††úúz¼ƒÈ›nݺ•W2ËÅ,æŸ?oüýý�9Â,}Úl6c:sæ Wˆ»»;‚��³Ý¶mÛäÉ“wïÞM}€£ÍÎÎî­·ÞbŒM�: nܸqñâE¡G¬Â;Œ1—={ö�F<¢4t 6j ­VëââOŸ>åµ×¯_ÿæ›o ))ÉËË‹Ó;::"N¢^^^Z­VàéééùùçŸGEEÕÖÖîÞ½ÛÃÃÕÁ÷“\J‡… vvvž9s†sàqŽ�gåÊ•þþþ¤®l6›ýýý³²²êëë¯\¹Â¡ãççÇóóó+,, Ú¹sg}}=Â.88·ÁÔäóçÏ/,,ìëëÛºu+�È„&[[ÛŒŒŒÌÌÌ[·nåæær¿ç>ÉÍ�yìÑÁÁaåÊ•W¯^Å�$Œ?)µZmddd]]5›°?[[[ÄMQQÑ©S§� ê“ËöñÇ;991ÆøîéСCŒ¸(÷sŒ:Ó¦M›6mÚž={ 99™ï…yt aâ×B5c,00/ïÞ½ËH\)))A{ງ1ƒ­pFÓét999ˆ'xë­·¶lÙRRRâè蘗—WQQ�hCþ¸óç·µµÝ¸qãàà`~~>ï—#à/ù ,;;;$$dË–-|±`ÁÆØŒ3rss›šš0Ø"Á‚ êëëñvOVVÎ5xàæàà�““ƒ±A³cÇŽ¤¤¤†††�?þØl6_½z»X·nG�»»{lllMMÍŒ3jjjrrrx¼áîG/ñÆB'$$8`6›Ñro¼ñ†ƒƒƒ��݆ OŸ>-@‘áèèh6›CCCkjj¦L™²{÷îS§N™Íf<Ù_´h‘§§'clÊ”)¥¥¥:�îĉld¡ÓÞÞ~ýúu ¬­­ Õ[\\¼wï^HIIÁx!ø* ¢œø}fzÃ9%%eÕªU&“ ·!š‘ÅÅÅ< ¤§§£ 4MQQ��4�ºÆuáââ¢×ëŸ>}Êoj¤»¤ô—ÆLΣ©�©�cÎÎÎxï�ž� yXŒs£ÂÈJTLÖ! Á OÅVò—Z d:XYÃòèäKª(™ŒÒX‡É,�€«µR8Ä‘÷÷÷Ož JС%˜„ÉE�_±\&SÜXý&“Q‚(‚pBTç#”Ëåæ2uÔ$[—;œÆr7„UÂË£”ÞúÐõ"4<2=====�×fee)ZNf+„F+¶Q‹VzùÍ8DÙZ‡—\Ȥy†×¾ò§?ýIàE€P¨˜„˜FË­Åu!sPd¥ÆŸ;·šl¿Çke9I”¬§§ÇËË —h˜öîÝûóÏ?1­ \��ÌS6¤Z¹¢„VF'CÐ:°@Š,�ÀGãééi}ʠ繿g £—Ât 8»ÉÍAiù=óe¨>aN�ÿSЉ‰yÿý÷ø£ƒL ü\Ȩ¨å­ÊXÑX.¥Õb‰ 3o ê§‚r•Åæœó¢fÜZ %;)F9!£æ©Â|ÁKÔú’ÏohGŠ*¦=þÄß.RófÊÙJ8Qœåe2¹”ìJC‘Ú&ŒZˆ^fé_¹zùëK VðAmFOóh’E±>ñ©iŸÇù¾„Я`!zQÝÉú¥Är†'|ž„f‚dEÅ5�YJ  _qtŠpò”XvKŠahs2p)ÂxÉ(kŠX±".�Ljá„WÉ4Òi� }J#¨Xh+† £v#L±;+ÚÇ<»HMj %j'ËŠ ÕL`jüW�X �=D 7œþ•?þñ�jËžÔ–Šr£Ù(±õÈ,Û ¶mÛ¶iÓ&6ò¤G̯(˜`TA2™!Å ¾óURRÂ_ÚUl5a„ãÇ�»¹¹�F|:àÿk†š7o^yyùĉ/\¸ ;=û¥K—‚ƒƒàÎ�;�Ê¢b‘UAQE9CñS¹�\ËoÆ ¿ô(‰J SRRJJJœ��i+¹Óëââ¢Óé’““ÐËyל^8ñ¤âUUU]»v-;;›‘çpñ¨ØNNNëׯ¿råÊ•+W¦N�*Óg„ñ]X“É„htBÞ¤›;wnqqñºuë˜åƒÏ”R«Õ®X±¢µµµµµµ­­­¡¡aåÊ•7nÔét­­­(Œb_z½^¯×{{{ÿýï/--Õëõò©º»ÈÉ €dsÿúâ0eÍ,±BËeF´�–¬^½º«««¬¬LQ³®®®Ó§OG�Ággçäää7n´··{{{#7—mÛ¶9;; b„‡‡·¶¶¶´´Ð*Aút-oXWWÇQ…) àÈ‘#üýQÎP°^¢yîÝ»'�ÓâÅ‹¸ø¼&¦+V¬X±BÖ$clîܹçÏŸwqq øàƒž>}šœœŒµ¶¶Ê¶˜>}úöíÛ;::.]ºÄ»˜>}zAAíÂlù|´ EG¢H�¥åªáÅaÊ”'ºp%ô’I“‚�� †¸¸¸ªª*JƒC€'Ož`P]²d ~¤µµõàÁƒ­­­z½>""bÕªU...ÇŽÛ»wo[[Ú ð11£ÑøäÉA*ooo|}¬­­M×ÀÀ†4”gÞ¼y}ôÑæÍ›/\¸°bÅ hhhË•UF|1�@£ÑhµÚà;$ŸþyMM Ì�;wþüùóæÍûàƒÚÚÚ°¼½½“““?ûì3|î˜1†þ€�ö�Fþú—äĉ®®®pôèÑêêê'OžøøøÇÅÅ †S§N9r¤®®'S—���îînþž!µ,…‘lzaTf³YÜaÉ@a–“´Ì�žçRpäææéõúÈÈÈÊÊJÊÄÇÇG¯×�Fü¢Åüùó7G�ýÇ?þ� UWW3ÆRSS %%E ­­�»ÀWqM&>‡+HŽgzhû‰'~ôÑGÉÉɸӮ©©Näñ"2ø-´ª¾¾½råÊ{÷îaùùóç/\¸páÂ�NÈôæCà¸�‘ùƒ.}‰KKK7yyyøô4c¬»»»»»ÛÕÕuÁ‚®®®iiiiii´‹ŒŒ "Le[ Qz(@ àš±øª§P V}úky¼Á( øA#”Á`0à+úF£±ªªŠ7Z2�\0ÁöTfÅŒ"b„æØï¯oÊ=YIŠ›)�6>pøðaÀ/¤ ±Á`puu­¬¬üïÿËÃ%‘Ñhlnn–¡Í×ËèIÈ �Fã�;whÔ ïïïGcÐ7‰@§ÓmÛ¶ «ŒFã´iÓ¼½½‹‹‹…A™•^½ãýb0¸{÷.ýƒ6òf>(­j‘ô÷÷siçÏŸRhÔét………<¦ò!¯Y³¦¬¬ ¬¥¥ehhH°‘ÙlF5>yò„— [*ÚD^ãÓ°'4‘›3:a�´®fJèS«RÛn0Æjkk@¯×ûøø`I\\\?ÿÐÆy|ï‚Y"��@õŻ擥tqqIMMÅåŒøùè<äð&_|ñÒã(„|âĉÜêú)ÍfóŽ;ôz=NFˆ�N·cÇŽ´´4þúÑBj‹   hjj’CG'N.g’÷ʘl˜4¹W5^Â~^� ‡††p® ÁUTTP(ÈŠ@Îz½Þ`0À¹sç¸~¹Þ……Naaauu5Ç“^¯çU›7o ÌÎÎFÛ¶¶¶b�S”�‘D»À%*N…¼vÕªUôƒ~B2›Í¸@éïïç1¡/4)++›>}ú'Ÿ|ƒŠ��ÏéÓ§ CbbbUUoBeã¸AtÒe�Z¢V¦:h¬s`ü#)2;�ÍÈÇíÌ1‚ÛáxÐ-š››kkk9ºýðOK–,Ñëõ---8ëñ`€&¤”………Œ1<ÀY)88˜1æíí]ZZºdÉ’ììì;wî õz}uu5‘âI†àHŠ: NMMå­ÂÝMz½~õêÕ0²ÆæjÓ§OgŒMŸ>ý«¯¾2 [·nmjjÂÑ@NNNww÷²eËš››Íf3*Šo* ~\l×®]Ož<¡˧ râ &�,W{L2·Åi² &!ƒI™÷*w� ßÜöõõ]ºtiPPЮ]»(Oœ¹ôz}||///**ª»»û½÷Þ£ô<ïëë»lÙ2þ릦¦ÆÆÆ¦¦&ùŽ,–¤§§ÇÇÇ£Þ‹ŠŠ2* ÏŒ3æÔ©SF£ñí·ßF8Z9VP¼Ì‹‹‹Ã·³gÏVWWã$ÂÆÅÅEFF¢JqÍve³ …ñññÈÐ××·¹¹(Ї„„,[¶lÆŒxY^^~æÌùƒß �F @ÐÈÇ12¶n¿ª”.ÙdÖeäa^vV@–——�»GÙÒBž"O�FíÒz•`<VÕn¹„T‹[2"znª„„ü¾É?ÿùÏŠŠŠÜÜÜeË–566Òç Õ†\+d¬× #µÒJÐÃ#A� ¦µ@éY2�’r@ÊÐÐÐèèèÔÔÔÿüç? äÜB„  åSGEí g•е‚üüRƒ�ÌñÂd-h3t) ˆ­h3y>Ž1”››;f̘¦¦¦œœŒO¸„  ^¹SÅÀ _Ê�G­Ö æd á寷?å ÏW„¬P5ñòI“&íÝ»wÇŽ§OŸV£Q˜FzCO†…ÌGöKYƒ`‰!+bX)Tô4¡GEæXž‘‘ÁwFxþ‹”cÆŒ€îînyP aQîH R‚hYk˜8ndÉÝàehhègŸ}VXXXVV&7Z …,¹­*µ±P Ð.Ì*ïTXaE‡©¨+žh˜¡8‹ŒŒDÜ|üñÇxjŠI§Óùúú�Fü^�ÌJPÕXz—<+['Y ü—ÚëwÎùq£“bµš?�;g¥7ß|ó¯ýëÛo¿�¸dâ­€Z%{¶<…)2) 2ÿ&2(CEJY-òè@éŸfÿ­çÚµkxÄÅËñ yû÷ï§w” ±A–ß ¦­‡"ë…ÂpF©yžì+òúQVÓ_|Áÿ‡vhh(66u¬¸µ<+©1WÔ¨`Âú*ÊJR ¨\kŠC�/#¥ÜopòË1cÆ$&&þûßÿFgã:‘›ËÞeE3B++ª\QqŒ¼¯WìììèSfG e[ ”ø±Ì‚‚‚ŒŒŒ(.`ÕXY/‘cÒ|'O& 4j�Š‘D/Õ¤R rVäÿé§ŸBCC=<<^¼x�[ë… îØ±ãØ±cøÄ’"æäÙVX‹ÈJ È´¡h+p§Uü”µ€Å~'½ÿ!‡.¬Ô0A)ÚO0VÌ,«±R”ÄJäSëNM9–“)ýo.°€¨[‘Æz‰ÜµÐ¯P%7·"H€�;’òÂÿnÐ^ endstream endobj 4 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Form /FormType 1 /Filter /FlateDecode /BBox [0.000000 0.000000 595.276000 76.535433] /Matrix [1 0 0 1 0 0] /Resources << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI] /Font << /F2 5 0 R /F1 3 0 R >> /XObject << /I1 31 0 R >> >> /Length 273 >> stream xœÅ’OKÃ@Åïùï¨ “ý7›Ä›U[ìMÍ­ô’6­˜¤]úõÝTCƒJ ºË°»ïÍo‡ÙC*C‘2F$~ë„tl-[E,3”¢$b6 ò áƒÄ]ƒÇ`’"œ*HIâ¸�®qŸ‚8:>Þmîã‹¥? 3e°‡$_/®„7öfî”;xß>+£„"iY3X’a¡#-°¸¸©;×í2ÜnëÌ].‘Î{É£„ÿÁ¨cе:1ví¦qW˜t®ÞÖ%Ö�ÃÔ­VES�ˆÿMYÒ#´MÛî®Ã0{ïbÞ7‘òOX1ƒ5”(Î1=Í0Ö«èûº`4˜‚¤ý`V`V±Õrœ~Åóok¿ B®´ endstream endobj 2 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI] /Font << /F1 3 0 R /F2 5 0 R /F3 7 0 R >> /XObject << /XT4 4 0 R /I1 31 0 R >> >> endobj 6 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 8 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 9 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 10 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 11 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 12 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 13 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 14 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 15 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 16 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 17 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 18 0 obj <> /H /I>> endobj 32 0 obj << /Title (þÿNurturing of the Pakistan Plant) /Author (þÿAnurupa Cinar) /Creator (þÿWP Post to PDF plugin by Neerav Dobaria \(http://www.techna2.com/blog\) with TCPDF) /Producer (þÿTCPDF 5.9.178 \(http://www.tcpdf.org\)) /CreationDate (D:20131115145715+00'00') /ModDate (D:20131115145715+00'00') /Trapped /False >> endobj 33 0 obj << /Type /Metadata /Subtype /XML /Length 4355 >> stream application/pdf Nurturing of the Pakistan Plant Anurupa Cinar 2013-11-15T14:57:15+00:00 WP Post to PDF plugin by Neerav Dobaria (http://www.techna2.com/blog) with TCPDF 2013-11-15T14:57:15+00:00 2013-11-15T14:57:15+00:00 TCPDF TCPDF 5.9.178 (http://www.tcpdf.org) uuid:912020df-93e9-e8a8-8818-912c0d1fa553 uuid:912020df-93e9-e8a8-8818-912c0d1fa553 http://ns.adobe.com/pdf/1.3/ pdf Adobe PDF Schema http://ns.adobe.com/xap/1.0/mm/ xmpMM XMP Media Management Schema internal UUID based identifier for specific incarnation of a document InstanceID URI http://www.aiim.org/pdfa/ns/id/ pdfaid PDF/A ID Schema internal Part of PDF/A standard part Integer internal Amendment of PDF/A standard amd Text internal Conformance level of PDF/A standard conformance Text endstream endobj 34 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Version /1.7 /Pages 1 0 R /Names << >> /ViewerPreferences << /Direction /L2R >> /PageLayout /SinglePage /PageMode /UseNone /OpenAction [19 0 R /FitH null] /Metadata 33 0 R >> endobj xref 0 35 0000000000 65535 f 0000011881 00000 n 0000022924 00000 n 0000011976 00000 n 0000022347 00000 n 0000012082 00000 n 0000023070 00000 n 0000012193 00000 n 0000023484 00000 n 0000023898 00000 n 0000024312 00000 n 0000024727 00000 n 0000025142 00000 n 0000025557 00000 n 0000025981 00000 n 0000026405 00000 n 0000026829 00000 n 0000027253 00000 n 0000027677 00000 n 0000000015 00000 n 0000000467 00000 n 0000001886 00000 n 0000002362 00000 n 0000004180 00000 n 0000004650 00000 n 0000006820 00000 n 0000007305 00000 n 0000009189 00000 n 0000009674 00000 n 0000010777 00000 n 0000011262 00000 n 0000012307 00000 n 0000027950 00000 n 0000028441 00000 n 0000032879 00000 n trailer << /Size 35 /Root 34 0 R /Info 32 0 R /ID [ <912020df93e9e8a88818912c0d1fa553> <912020df93e9e8a88818912c0d1fa553> ] >> startxref 33089 %%EOF Nurturing of the Pakistan Plant – Anurupa Cinar

Nurturing of the Pakistan Plant

“Judge not by the glib words spoken with a forked tongue, judge by the actions that follow them.�

–         Anurupa Cinar

 

Hi, Everyone! In March 1940, the Muslim League made a formal demand for Pakistan. And by May 1940, Gandhi started talking with a forked tongue!

While researching Gandhi I have noticed he has a remarkable talent for expressing two opposing ideas and making them seem reasonable. The unpleasant point is made in a negative form and the one intended to be applauded, quoted, and publicized is made very positively.

I am giving a prime example of it below:

“‘As a man of nonviolence,’ he [Gandhi] observed, ‘I cannot forcibly resist the proposed partition if the Muslims of India really insist upon it.’�

That’s the negative form, and a euphemistic way of really saying he will accept Pakistan—for the Muslims in India were most certainly insisting upon it . . . !

In the next sentence he says:

“But I can never be a willing party to the vivisection. . . .�[1]

How very much this sentence been quoted . . . ! Though, even in that there is a catch, for he can claim to be an “unwilling� party to the vivisection. There’s his out.

See how it is? I intend to devote a whole post one day to highlighting many of Gandhi’s such double-talk.

Congress was certainly wishing to get rid of Jinnah. Pakistan plan was insidiously being spoken off in an agreeable way. Check out what Gandhi has to say— openly published in his Harijan —to an Englishman.

“While answering an Englishman, Gandhi replied in Harijan of May 4, 1940: ‘I would any day prefer Muslim rule to British rule. . . . The partition proposal had altered the face of Hindu-Muslim problem. . . .’ And he granted that “Pakistan cannot be worse than foreign domination.’�

And Keer further asks, as a comment on this flimflaming of Gandhi’s:

“Was it an explanation of his stand or a direction for the Muslim leaders to draw up their plans?�[2]

By 1942, Congress was done with these oblique references to accepting Pakistan. Jinnah and the Muslim League were becoming a big hindrance in their path. Viceroy Linlithgow was not entertaining their demands, especially ones that aimed at giving Congress sole power in free India. The Congress High Command now made a drastic, treacherous move.

“The Working Committee of the Indian National Congress proclaimed emphatically by a resolution at Delhi in April 1942, ‘that the Congress could not think in terms of compelling the people of any territorial unit to join the Indian Union against their declared and established will.’

This historic resolution brought into bold relief the fact that the Congress favoured the provinces with the right of self-determination or secession and such secession was called by the Muslims ‘Pakistan.’

Dealing with Congress resolution four years later, Dr. Pattabhi Sitaramayya had to admit: ‘It is evident that the passage concedes the division of India into more than one State and gives the go-by to the Unity and integrity of India.’�[3]

Pakistan resolution was now passed by the Congress Working Committee . . . ! And that in April 1942—five years before Partition and independence.

The All-India Congress Committee, though, was as yet clueless re this treacherous resolution of their Working Committee.

Now the Congress High Command had to ensure that the A.I.C.C. too accepted the Pakistan resolution. Rajagopalachari set to work to do the deed.

“On 23April 1942 Rajagopalachari managed to get two resolutions passed by the Congress members in the Madras legislature. The first recommended to the All-India Congress Committee (which was about to meet in Allahbad) that Congressmen should acknowledge the Muslim League’s claim for separation, should the same be persisted in when the time came for framing the constitution of India . . . The resolution urged that ‘to sacrifice the chances of the formation of a national government for the doubtful advantage of maintaining a controversy over the unity of India is the most unwise policy’ and that it had become necessary to choose the lesser evil. . . .

The Muslim League was naturally jubilant at its ideal of Pakistan having been brought down at last from the clouds of speculation to the level of practical politics . . .

The All-India Congress Committee, meeting in Allahabad on 29 April, rejected his resolution by an overwhelming majority and adopted a counter-resolution ‘that any proposal to disintegrate India by giving liberty to any component State or territorial unit to secede from the Indian Union or Federation will be detrimental to the best interests of the people of the different States and provinces and the country as a whole and the Congress, therefore, cannot agree to any such proposal.’�[4]

The Congress members were not in favor of their High Command’s sellout of the Motherland. They stated so, unequivocally in their resolution.

But the Congress High Command who were absolute dictators of the Congress (and had disregarded, overturned, and schemed against relatively minor issues) were not about to let their Delhi resolution of acceding Pakistan, upon which depended their getting total power in free India (or so they believed,) be swept away.

“Upon this Dr. Sayyid Abdul Latif of Hyderabad asked Maulana Azad whether Jagat Narayan’s resolution had in any way modified or affected the Delhi resolution of the Working Committee. Maulana Azad in his letter of August 6, 1942, replied: ‘No part of the Delhi resolution to which you refer has in any way been affected or modified by any subsequent resolution of the A.I.C.C.’�

 “To the same question of Dr. Latif, Jawaharlal Nehru also replied that Babu Jagat Narayan’s ‘resolution does not in any way override the Delhi Working Committee resolution.’�[5]


 

·       So the Congress Working Committee resolution acceding  Pakistan reigned supreme—as affirmed by the Congress dictators on August 6, 1942.

Read on to discover the Machiavellian timing of this Delhi resolution . . .

Anurupa


[1] Mahatma Gandhi, Dhananjay Keer, Page 682.

[2] Mahatma Gandhi, Dhananjay Keer, Page 682-683.

[3] Veer Savarkar, Dhananjay Keer, page 307.

[4]Transfer of Power, V. P. Menon, page 139.

[5]Mahatma Gandhi, Keer, page 700.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CAPTCHA Image

*

Catch Everest Theme by Catch Themes